It’s never pretty when you lose control. Even if it’s brief, it exposes a raw side of you that you generally want to keep suppressed and concealed from the outside world. But I snapped. We were staying with her friend / play partner last weekend on our road trip. They had already played many times, spent the night together in his bedroom while I slept in the other, etc. I was fine. Well honestly a little grumpy, but not angry or sad. My confusion started because she had asked me a week or so earlier if I would be comfortable with her flying up here to start spending weekends with this man, but yet when we arrived and he asked if she was spending the whole weekend, she didn’t seem at all enthused about the idea. Was it because I was here with her that she didn’t jump at the idea of extending our stay for the whole weekend? That was the only guess I had. Then Saturday after a big lunch and too many carbs, she and I laid down for a nap while he was gone doing some personal errands. I was extra sleepy because somewhere along the way I picked up a sniffle in NY, so when she got up to watch tv in the other room I rolled over and got some more rest. I woke up a bit later and I could tell he had gotten home, they were watching tv together and chatting in the living room. I nodded off again and this time when I woke up, the tv was blasting from the other room. I couldn’t take the noise so I got up to check on it and the room was empty, the bedroom door closed. Not a shocker. I turned down the tv to a reasonable volume and grabbed a water out of his fridge and by the time I made the 20 foot walk back to the guest room (it’s a tiny 2 bedroom apt, not a mansion), they both came busting out of the bedroom. He plopped quickly down in his chair in front of the tv and she dashed naked into the hall bathroom.
And I snapped.
My synapses made the instantaneous connection between me turning down the tv (alerting them that I had woken up) and them rushing out of the room like two little kids caught doing something they had no business doing. My mind put those two things together and it immediately blared out the question inside my head … “What could they have possibly have been doing that they felt the need to hide from me?”. Quickly followed by a statement “more secrets”.I snapped. Flashbacks took over my vision and instead of seeing red, I saw her previous actions and secrets and lies all played back in a quick montage that left me reeling. I can only compare it to the experience people describe as seeing your life pass before your eyes, but in this case not my life but all the pain of the past year. After all we have been through and here we are spending two nights in another city with your lover and yet you two feel the need to shut the door every time you do something (like I wouldn’t know what was happening) and now even the closed door apparently wasn’t providing you a significant enough level of secrecy, whatever was happening had to be done with me asleep.
So I snapped.Nothing violent, no lashing out. I simply grabbed my keys, put on my shoes and went to kiss her goodbye. She was shocked, asked where I was going, and I told her I was going to give them the private time they obviously want and need so they don’t have to feel the need to dash out and put on a show for me. She protested. Told me not to go. Told me they had just been fucking and had finished which is why they happened to come out at that moment. But I don’t believe in coincidence. I can’t accept the fact that they had three hours alone while I slept and within a minute of them knowing I was awake they just happened to dash out of the room. Too many times with her previous lover she played off coincidences which later turned out to be lies.So I left them there. Whatever they felt the need to conceal from me they were free to indulge themselves in without me there to interrupt. But then the text messages began. Pleas to return, promises that there was nothing being concealed, disbelief that I flew off like I did. I rode around a strange city, wandering while my mind tried to work itself out and my heart tried to pull on an even deeper reserve of love. Finally she asked me to come back and get her, at least let’s have this conversation in person instead of over text. So I found my way back to his place, picked her up, and we spent hours in the parking lot of a convenience store talking about the night, our lives, our joys and pain and all we had lost that would never be regained. The trust. The excitement of our lives together and our adventures, sexual and otherwise. Everything now is tainted. I didn’t realize all of me that had been lost until she pointed out those things she hadn’t seen in me for months now. The happiness that used to flow from me, the look on my face at seeing her, showing the love that filled me to overflowing, all for her. After a life of hiding my authentic self in one miserable failed relationship after another, I had found someone I could be myself with. She was that person who saw all of me and loved me for who I was and not what I could promise to become or who she could change me into. Our imperfections made us fit perfectly together.
But now I doubt. I don’t know what’s real anymore. When she tells me they weren’t doing anything they needed to hide and she wouldn’t hurt me and she’s being honest … I want to believe and accept what she is saying at face value, but she said all of that to me word for word a few months ago while looking in my eyes like she is now, and every word was a well crafted lie. She showed no hesitation lying to my face with a smile on hers when she was trying to protect the secrets only she and her love shared, so how do I now believe the words and the promises from that same mouth? What is different? What has changed? She still can’t give me any insight into why she felt the need to lie to me and keep her feelings, actions and love hidden from me for all those months. Can’t tell me why she would lie to me so many times in the last few months about everything to do with him. Lie to me while I’m in front of her begging for honesty, willing to forgive the past for the hope of our future if she can just pull us out of our tailspin and get us back to the open communication and honesty that we based our relationship on. So if I can’t know why she would lie then, how can I ever hope to accept that she is not lying now?
So we talk for hours. Standing in front of a store in a strange city until 1 am. We talk and we cry and we both ask the question of how do we get back what we’ve lost. And we both have the same answer. We can’t. We will never have what we did for four and a half years. We will never share a love untainted by lies and deceit. So is what we have left enough? Can we limp this broken and bleeding (she added infected) relationship along for the rest of our lives? Me not trusting her and her not wanting to keep talking about what happened because she doesn’t feel it will solve anything. We go back to his place and eat some leftovers and get some sleep for the road trip home in the morning. She sleeps in the guest room with me instead of with him, not because she wants to necessarily, but because he is already in bed when we return and when she goes in to see him, he doesn’t offer his bed to her.The next morning is strained. Neither of us slept very well and we have almost ten hours in the car together today to make it home. After quick showers and a goodbye to her friend (somewhat strained for me after last night’s incident and not knowing what she may have shared with him about why I left suddenly), we grabbed breakfast and got on the road. The beginning of the trip was quiet, she slept while I drove and when she took over, I dozed myself. It wasn’t until we were about three hours from home that we broke the silence that had been with us since breakfast. I had been writing this blog on my phone, and when I got to what felt like the ending (not just of the blog, but potentially of our relationship), I simply couldn’t let that be the close.
That was two paragraphs earlier, when I posed the question, “how can I ever hope to accept that she is not lying now?” So I posed it. I shared with her where my mind was after last night and I told her that I wasn’t ready to throw in the towel, but I needed her help. I needed to understand what else I could have done this weekend to prevent the downward spiral. What followed was a long conversation that took us the last few hours home to Atlanta and then kept going for several more hours once we unpacked the car. I came away with insights for myself into what I could have done, no, should have done that night to make things different. Rather than internalize my doubts over her seeming flip-flop on wanting to stay weekends with her lover, I should have taken her aside and asked why. Then she could have told me she hadn’t decided that was something she really wanted to do, she had simply been asking to gauge my response and get an understanding for how much I had healed from the wounds left by her last lover. I could also have told her I was bothered by the door being shut every time they went into his room or the fact that they acted like they barely knew one another in the living room, but would then slip in his bedroom and play for hours at a time with the door closed. Or I could have asked her the first morning, after she shared his bed most of the evening and all night, why she wouldn’t come to me the next morning and feed me her swollen pussy. But instead, I kept all of these thoughts inside and doing so put me on edge, so that when they just happened to come out of the room after I woke up, I was already poised to snap. I realized that I have developed a pattern of holding in as much concern and frustration as I can until I reach a boiling point and I made a commitment to begin speaking my mind immediately rather than letting my questions, anger and frustrations build up. As we continued our discussion, she realized that she had developed a similar pattern of holding back information, but for different reasons. In her case, she was reluctant to share information when she didn’t have her own time to mull something over and look at it from every angle. In many cases this prevented her from sharing things with me at all because she would come up with disastrous scenarios where telling me caused a terrible reaction, where she waited too long so that telling me now seemed like she had been holding out or where she just waited too long and forgot. The problem with all of these was that I was in the dark. Whether it was intentional or not on her part, I ended up not knowing what she was doing, thinking and most importantly feeling. As we talked through what had happened over the weekend, she began to reveal in greater detail some of the things that she and her lover had done and more importantly to me, some of the things they had discussed behind that closed door. These were all things she hadn’t told me the day before. Things she had either deemed not important enough to share or things she wasn’t sure how to take herself so she kept them to herself, but sharing them had a dual effect. For me, it gave me a sense of comfort that she was sharing her heart and mind with me, finally. For her, it gave her a sounding board so that she could get my viewpoint on those things she wasn’t sure of herself and we could talk them through.
And I didn’t snap.
She realized that the reality of sharing things with me when they happen, raw and unfiltered / unedited wasn’t the train wreck she was afraid it would be. I didn’t overreact when I found out that he asked her in the midst of sex if it was “more than just sex” for her. Nor did I explode when she told me she had to pause and she couldn’t answer him directly one way or the other because she wasn’t sure herself. She realized what I had known for some time now … that allowing me inside her shell didn’t mean she was exposed, it meant that she and I were both protected. We were able to talk through the night and morning at a different level than we had in some time, maybe different than we ever had before. We both felt that we had made progress and we were closer than we had been in many months.
Had we snapped … back? I certainly hope so.
We sealed our mental and emotional breakthrough with intimacy. That too had been missing. We’ve had sex, but it’s been irregular and the barriers that have built up over the last nine months are there in bed with us most days, but not this time. We enjoy one another fully that morning and again and again over the next few days.
We aren’t back to what we were and as we both agreed that Saturday night, we never will be. But for the first time in nine months I can hope that we may find our way back to something that will make us both happy, maybe even something more than what we had before.